Al-Sarira
  • Home
  • Saudi Arabia
  • UAE
  • Bahrain
  • Yemen
  • Qatar
  • Afghanistan
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Syria
  • Lebanon
  • Palestine
  • Israel
No Result
View All Result
Al-Sarira
  • Home
  • Saudi Arabia
  • UAE
  • Bahrain
  • Yemen
  • Qatar
  • Afghanistan
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Syria
  • Lebanon
  • Palestine
  • Israel
No Result
View All Result
Al-Sarira
No Result
View All Result

Afghanistan and Palestine Mirror US Failure to Learn from Similar Mistakes

Nayib AbrahambyNayib Abraham
August 18, 2021
in Afghanistan, Palestine, Politics
0
Afghanistan and Palestine Mirror US Failure to Learn from Similar Mistakes

Hamid Karzai gives a medal to then US President George W. Bush in Kabul. Photo: Al-Sarira

US mission in both Afghanistan and Palestine concluded with an embarrassing lesson; Invasion and intervention starts the path of defeat.

Under the most optimal circumstance, forming a military structure to suit the purposes of an invading force is a difficult goal. The United States has finally realized this, though not in time. Recent developments in Afghanistan confirmed this fact. We have also had other examples in the same era.

The annihilation of Mahmoud Abbas militants, who had US military and monetary supports, dates back to less than 15 years ago. Resistance forces imposed a defeated and dispersed the group as occurred in Afghanistan.

Regardless of their actual contrasts on various levels, the US ventures in Afghanistan and Palestine had a number of commonalities.

The Bush government turned down numerous offers to involve the Taliban in a political solution after crushing them two decades ago. High-rank Taliban commanders called Hamid Karzai, the fresh president, with offers to lay down guns and participate in democratic process. Donald Rumsfeld, then the US Secretary of Defense, refused all these offers outright.

Despite the denials at primary stages, the Taliban persisted in pressuring Karzai, who in turn pushed the US to initiate a political discussion. The attempts were entirely thwarted, resulting in the regime’s prohibition on any interaction with the Taliban.

The same US approach toward the Palestinian movement, particularly Hamas, was certainly even more aggressive. Interestingly, once the group secured majority in the elections in 2006, which were expected to boost the democratic reform, the US conduct started to entail more offense.

The Palestinian Authority didn’t have authority to interact with Hamas, as was the case about Karzai government. Following the elections, Hamas attempted to form “national unity government” with Fatah, but the latter firmly rejected, purportedly under pressure from Washington. 

Afghanistan and Palestine; Two Missions with One Lesson

Washington’s workbook in Afghanistan and Palestine is majorly sabotaging political initiatives. As such, the blame is on the United States for the destabilization of both nations. The abuse of military and paramilitary groups has fueled persistent frustrations and divisions. In a similar way, the suppression of political rivals and critics has harmed political and democratic processes.

Fledgling security forces in Afghanistan and Palestine faced with a similar challenge. To put in a nutshell, they had no choice but to be everything all at once. While the Palestinian militia had the onerous burden of balancing concerns of Israel and Palestine, the Afghan security forces’ task ranged from fighting rebels and controlling terrorist attacks to tracking down drug lords and containing the development of opium.

Washington’s mission and its goals is still in haze following all of the wars, the fatalities and damage that followed them. “Our commitment to democracy is also challenged in the Middle East, which is my emphasis, and must be a focus of American policy for decades to come,” President Bush said in November 2003, shortly after 9/11.

18 years later, different vibes from the White House perplexed the already bizarre mission. “Our mission in Afghanistan was never to create a unified democracy,” Joe Biden said in justifying the US withdrawal. Joe Biden’s remarks further reinforced the theory that the United States supplies the perplexity to further secure its interests.  

Military occupations, regardless of their roots or ideology, are inherently hostile to democracy and progress. Their most innocuous manifestations also breed opposition and thwart the sustainable and inclusive development. Examples include Afghanistan and Palestine. Afghans and Palestinians have been subject to countless assaults and colonization throughout history. The United States has now reached the end of line after twenty years.

Tags: Afghanistan WarPalestine IssueTalibanUS in AfghanistanUS in Palestine

Related Posts

Syrian president in UAE; Assad Boosts Ties with former Allies
Politics

Syrian President in UAE; Assad Boosts Ties with Former Allies

March 20, 2023

UAE is Bashar Al-Assad's second destination after long years of isolation during the civil war in Syria. For the first...

Ehud Barak to Protesters: 'Disobey the Law'
Society

Ehud Barak to Protesters: ‘Disobey the Law’

March 19, 2023

In the event that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's proposed set of judicial reforms is put into effect, a former Israeli...

Will Netanyahu’s Disregard For People of Israel Topple His Beloved Government?
Politics

Will Netanyahu’s Disregard For People of Israel Topple His Beloved Government?

March 19, 2023

With complete disregard for weeks-long protests in Israel against the law that would weaken the Supreme Court, Netanyahu is indeed...

Iran’s Ali Shamkhani Heads to Iraq After Visiting China and UAE
Politics

Iran’s Ali Shamkhani Heads to Iraq After Visiting China and UAE

March 18, 2023

After visiting high-ranking officials in China and the UAE, Secretary of Iran’s Supreme National Security Council Ali Shamkhani will go...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

POPULAR POSTS

  • Under Bin Salman, Saudi Arabia Declares Open Season on Islam

    Under Bin Salman, Saudi Arabia Declares Open Season on Islam

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Where is Emad al-Moubayed? Activists Demand Saudi Arabia

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Syrian President in UAE; Assad Boosts Ties with Former Allies

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Benny Gantz: “Escalation Is Desirable” For Bezalel Smotrich

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Ehud Barak to Protesters: ‘Disobey the Law’

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Next Post
Naftali Bennett's Visit to Washington; A Desperate Attempt to Contain Iran's Regional Influence

Bennett's Visit to Washington; A Desperate Attempt to Contain Iran's Regional Influence

al-sarira
Contact Us
About Us

© Copyright 2021 - All rights reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Saudi Arabia
  • UAE
  • Bahrain
  • Yemen
  • Qatar
  • Afghanistan
  • Iran
  • Iraq
  • Syria
  • Lebanon
  • Palestine
  • Israel

© 2023 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.